I have been listening to some audio tapes I have. I don’t think I even told you how I came across these tapes. On July 22, 2003, I received a phone call from a detective who informed me that Craig had been arrested for homicide, and he asked me to meet him at our Kaysville house. At the time I was at Shondells house (the counselor) and she was very concerned it was a set up. She thought Craig was trying to get me to the house for something. She asked me to leave my boys with her and said to make sure I knew it was safe before going into the house. So I drove the 10 minutes down to the house and as I approached the house I noticed cop cars on both sides of the street all the way up to my house. When I arrived at the house, it was surrounded in yellow Crime Scene tape, and the detectives were waiting for me in the driveway. I knew this was no set up. This was real. There was media everywhere.
They informed me that Craig had been arrested the night before, for homicide, and that they wanted me to know before it hit the news. This was about 3pm. By 5pm it hit the news and was on every channel every 15 minutes as Breaking News. They told me they needed to recover evidence from the house and that I was not allowed to enter the house until they were done, approximately a few days.
After getting a little bit of information and their cards, I left and went back to Shondell to pick up the boys. I told her it was very real and would be on the 5 o’clock news. On the way home, I had to explain to the boys what had happened. The saddest part of this is it was Roccos 10th birthday and we had a party planned at the pool where we lived, with all our family and friends. Obviously it turned out very differently than what we had planned, but I will go over that when we get further into the journal notes.
It took the detectives 3 days to recover all the evidence they wanted from our house. They carried many, many brown paper bags out of the house. During those 3 days I received a phone call from Craig's Real Estate agent who had listed the house for him. She informed me that Craig had not made a payment on the house for a year (basically since I had moved out) and that it was about to go into foreclosure. She said once it goes into foreclosure it would get locked up and everything in the house would be thrown out. She was giving me a heads up that if I wanted anything out of the house, I needed to do it asap.
Remember Craig had not allowed me to get anything out of that house when I moved out, so it was FULL of our things. I had less than 3 days to get everything out of this 7 bedroom home.
My neighbor kicked into gear and I will FOREVER be grateful to her for how quickly she arranged help. Within a day she had the whole neighborhood over there helping me get things packed onto a trailer, or sold on the front lawn. It was incredible.
I shouldn’t be telling you all of this yet, because it is premature, but I do have a point! While I was in our bedroom, clearing out closets etc, I came across a drawer FULL of audio tapes. I picked them up and noticed they all had dates on them. I couldn’t believe it. This is when I realized that Craig had been recording ALL of our conversations. But they weren’t just him and I. He had audio recorded his conversation with many others…..including Tamara Rhinehart (literally his partner in crime). I found the audio tape of the 2 of them discussing their final plans. I listened to it in the car driving home and when I arrived back in South Jordan, I called the detectives and they came over immediately to get it. I did however, get a chance to copy it before turning it over. So those of you on Patreon will get to hear that conversation. It still blows me away that the detectives never found these tapes. There was more evidence I found, but I will save that for later!
So this is why I have audio tapes. It has been surreal to listen to the tapes and hear Craig driving me crazy with his constant accusations and manipulation. It went on for a whole year.
Another thing I want to tell you, is how much the detectives used my journal notes after Craig was arrested, to track his activity before, during and after the crime happened. I obviously had no idea what was going on, but I wrote notes almost every day. After Craig was arrested, the detectives came over about 3 to 4 times a week and used my journal notes to trace his activity in the previous month. You never know when your journal will become evidence in a crime.
So this post is backtracking a bit because the last post I put up was about our CA trip in Feb. But I am going to give you some notes from the audio tape that he had marked 12/19/02. It just gives you some background as to what was going on.
Keep in mind that Craig was the one recording all of these conversations, and I had no idea. So he is careful about how he words things. I have no idea what his plan was for these tapes, but nevertheless, they are now in my hands as I write this story.
Side A starts off with Craig calling me and getting my voicemail. I won’t quote everything word for word, unless I feel it needs to be. He sounds despondent, and says I am arrogant, I have bipolar, I have an attitude that is horrendous. He asked me if I hung out with boyfriends the night before (I think this is what triggered the call, he probably couldn’t reach me and so therefore assumed I spent the nights with boyfriends). He said “Let's talk about bipolar, I have a reason to be angry. Chill out, drop the attitude and call me back. I am gone, I am out of the country. Please?”
So I returned his call and got his voicemail and even though he tried to call me back a few times while I was leaving his message, I wanted to finish so I didn’t pick up his call. I told him I have no choice, he made my life unbearable and I had to move out to be able to continue a semi normal life. I explained to him that I could not be with him anymore and that I was serious about moving on.
When he called back he was laughing at me. Almost making fun of me. Like my message was a joke. We had been discussing splitting our assets (the houses) the day before and and he told me I deserved nothing. He said he had never lied to me, never stabbed me in the back. All he was asking for was a commitment from me to our marriage. The more I talked about splitting assets, the more he asked me to commit to him. He said if I commit to him, he will discuss splitting equity with me. He said he is going to a foreign country to start a foreign business and will have nothing. At this point I think he was planning on heading back to SA because he was already in so much trouble here in the US, he had nowhere else to go.
I told him I don’t want any of his money, I just want my half of the equity. I had bought the West Valley house before he and I were even together. I had been in a car accident and received a fairly large payout so I used it to buy the house. He had since then taken out a second mortgage on it. We also had the house in South Jordan we needed to sell.
Craig told me he does not care one tiny bit if the kids and I have to go on welfare and get medicaid and food stamps. He would rather the State pay for our well being than take any money from him. He told me over and over again that I deserve nothing because I won’t commit to him.
We talked a lot about the work that needed to be done on the WV house, and I said I could hire someone to fix it up and then we could pay that out of the equity before we split it. He outright refused and said he will kick it around court until the cows come home.
Then he told me that ALL debt he has and would gain from that day forward, he was going to walk away from, and now that I know that, if I ask him for any money I will be considered an accomplice.
I hung up on him. I was disgusted.
Then he called me back sounding completely different and he said “Eve, lie to me! Tell me you love me, you will make love to me, tell me you’re sorry...then I will be fine. I just have a couple months left, just lie to me and then I’ll be gone” I told him if I did that he would call me in a few days fuming that I lied to him!
I told him I felt he was trying to screw me over. I knew he was trying to get all the money in his name so that he could leave, walk away from it and leave me with the fall.
We also discussed his affairs with Liz and Kathy. He brings up Michael (the man he convinced to come spend the night with me while Craig watched). He was convinced I had an affair with Michael. I told him he had affairs for more than 3 years (that I knew of) and he is upset about a 3 week friendship that he forced on Michael and I, and he played us like puppets? He said he didn’t leave me emotionally in those 3 years and that he was honorable. Holy Moly….the sad part is he really believed that. I don’t want to categorize men here, but I know men get less emotionally involved in sexual relationships and can just shut it down. But when you carry on with the same person for years…...there is emotion there.
In another part of the call, after he had said that he helps me out all the time and the least I could do was commit to him, I asked him what exactly he had done for me. He said that he had not filed police reports on me, he had not called my previous company to get me fired, and that he hadn’t turned my brother and sister into the INS even though they were actively participating in the destruction of his life. That is what he had done for me. I was speechless.
Then he asked me what I had done for him?
So I answered with the same kind of stupidity he was feeding me. I told him I had not reported him to the cable company for having illegal satellites, I hadn’t told the INS he he was running away and leaving the country to hide from them, and I had not reported to the credit card companies that he had no intention of ever paying his bills.
I felt ridiculous using these as honest efforts for showing someone I cared.
Craig also brought up I hadn’t dropped the protective order after I promised that I had. Well I never “promised” but the Victim's Advocates are there for a reason and they knew he was forcing me to go in and drop the order. He told me I had made my own bed, and now I get to sleep in it. He said again “I’m dead, you have killed me, I am gone”
Then we got into an argument about the coffee trailer. He had asked me to run it for a couple weeks for him so that he could work the WV house. I worked for the 2 weeks on the trailer, but he only spent 2 days on the West Valley house.
That does is for tonight! Thanks again for following along. We have over 23,400 views so I really appreciate all your support!
Until next time, Keep love in your heart!